Five Star Bank on Your Credit Report
In short: Five Star Bank is state-chartered and a Federal Reserve member, run out of Rochester, New York, and supervised by its state banking department and the Federal Reserve. It is an original creditor: it lends in its own name and reports the resulting account itself. It runs 48 offices and reports $6.29 billion in assets — a genuine multi-market regional footprint. That matters when you read a credit report: banks this size usually keep and service their own paper, so the name on the tradeline is normally the same institution you would dispute with. Information that is inaccurate, incomplete, or unverifiable can be disputed under the FCRA. Outcomes depend on what the furnisher can verify, and results vary.
Who Five Star Bank actually is
Charter details above are from the FDIC BankFind public database.
What makes this creditor different
Five Star Bank of Rochester, New York ran 48 offices and $6.29 billion in total assets as of June 30, 2026; its charter dates to December 26, 1881 and carries FDIC certificate 659. That makes it roughly 145 years old.
How Five Star Bank appears on your credit report
Five Star Bank is the furnisher of record, so the evidence that settles a dispute — ledger and statements — sits with the bank itself. FCRA §623(b) requires a furnisher that receives a bureau-forwarded dispute to investigate and to correct or delete what it cannot verify. With 48 offices the reporting function sits well away from the branch counter — put it in writing and keep proof of delivery.
Names it may report under
Products that commonly show up
- ◆Consumer and personal installment loans
- ◆Home equity lines and mortgages
- ◆Auto loans
- ◆Small-business loans personally guaranteed by an owner
Grounds to dispute a Five Star Bank entry
Each of these is a reason a Five Star Bank tradeline may be inaccurate or unverifiable. None of them assures removal — they are the angles worth checking on your own report.
- ◆A charter dating to the 1800s means decades of mergers; an account can still surface under a predecessor bank's name rather than as Five Star Bank
- ◆Loan paid off at Five Star Bank but still showing a balance after the payoff posted
- ◆A New York branch closure or consolidation changing how the account reports mid-term
- ◆Account balance or credit limit reported incorrectly
- ◆Payment reported late when it was made inside the grace period
- ◆Date of first delinquency re-aged to extend how long it can report
- ◆Account still reporting as open after it was closed, or vice versa
- ◆Duplicate tradeline for the same account after an internal transfer
- ◆Account belongs to someone else with a similar name, or is the result of identity theft
Disputing an original creditor is not the same as disputing a collector
Five Star Bank is an original creditor — the institution whose name was on the account when it was opened. That matters for two reasons. First, the FDCPA, which governs debt collectors, generally does not apply to a creditor collecting its own debt in its own name, so the “debt validation” request that works against a collection agency is not the right tool here. Second, as the furnisher of the tradeline, Five Star Bank has direct obligations under FCRA §623 to investigate a dispute you send it and to correct or delete information it cannot verify as accurate.
Dispute with the bureaus — FCRA §611
File with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. They must generally investigate within 30 days and tell the furnisher. Free, and you can do it yourself.
Dispute with the furnisher — FCRA §623
Send Five Star Bank a direct written dispute. It must investigate and must not continue reporting information it knows is inaccurate. Keep copies and proof of delivery.
Five Star Bank questions, answered
Who is Five Star Bank and why is it on my credit report?
Five Star Bank is state-chartered and a Federal Reserve member, headquartered in Rochester, New York, and supervised by its state banking department and the Federal Reserve. It carries FDIC certificate 659 and runs 48 offices. It shows up on a credit report as an original creditor, which means the account was opened directly with the bank — not bought from someone else. The FDIC records the charter as established December 26, 1881.
How do I dispute a Five Star Bank account?
Two routes exist and they are not the same. A bureau dispute under FCRA §611 generally requires investigation within 30 days and is forwarded to Five Star Bank; a direct dispute under FCRA §623 goes to the bank itself. Identify the account, say specifically what is wrong, attach statements or a payoff letter, and keep proof of delivery. With 48 offices the reporting function sits well away from the branch counter — put it in writing and keep proof of delivery.
Is Five Star Bank a collection agency?
No. Five Star Bank is the original creditor. A collector or debt buyer only enters the picture after an account goes delinquent. This matters because if an account was later sold, the Five Star Bank tradeline and a collector's tradeline can both appear. Once a balance is sold or transferred, the original account should not still show that same balance as owed — the same debt reported as outstanding twice is a specific, disputable inaccuracy.
How long can a Five Star Bank account stay on my report?
FCRA §605 allows most negative information to report for up to seven years, measured from the date of first delinquency that led to the negative status — not from charge-off, sale or last update. An account closed in good standing can remain longer and keeps contributing positive history. Re-aging that first-delinquency date to extend reporting is not permitted, so a date that has shifted is worth checking against your own records.
Other creditors on credit reports
This page is general information about consumer rights, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Crowned Credit is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Five Star Bank; company names are used only to identify the institution a consumer may see on a credit report. Crowned Credit does not promise any particular outcome; results vary by individual circumstances and by what a furnisher is able to verify. Accurate, verifiable information generally cannot be removed from a credit report. You have the right to dispute inaccurate information yourself, for free, directly with the credit bureaus and with the furnisher.
Ready to Remove Inaccurate Items from Your Credit Report?
Take the first step towards financial freedom today. Book a consultation with our credit repair experts.
You’ll only be charged if you enroll